RSS-Feed abonnieren

Passwort vergessen?

v Anmelden

18. Nov 2017

An experimental view on solidarity

Verfasst von

When concepts meet science

Is it not always a good idea to ‘translate’ abstract ideas or theories into more vivid, concrete, and, if possible, touchable forms? A word, a thought, might get unnoticed by many, if you do not take care to clothe them by an appropriate metaphor, by a brilliant sentence, by a proverb – or, by downsizing it to a well-known aspect of the physical world. Even if you don’t agree, you get an easy understandable base for further discussing, for deepening the subject. That is what a Malagasy student in social anthropology, Mr. Heriniaina Danielson Ralaivaha, has done.

Recently, by getting interested in the ongoing project on the “Dynamics of Solidarity on Madagascar”, he proposed me his own, original way to translate the possible importance of the notion of ‘solidarity’ for building up society, and to understand more about the historical journey of that idea on the island of Madagascar in particular. One afternoon, when we had agreed to meet for discussion, he arrived with a couple of empty plastic bottles and two funnels, ready for a surprise. As his presentation allows to approach the subject central to the DySoMa project from a different angle, it fits perfect into this blog. And this is what he presented.

The experiment

Experimental setup: About ten empty water bottles, two funnels, a bucket with water. Two individuals ready for a competition.

The experimental setup

Application: Everyone gets a funnel with the order to fill up as many bottles as possible within one minute. However, they have to keep the funnel in two opposite ways. The first person is allowed to keep the funnel ‘normal’, i.e. according to his function: The wider side of the funnel is therefore above, and the pipe below. The second person, though, gets the order to keep the funnel upside-down, i.e. the pipe is above, and the wider side of the funnel is below. Who will triumph, with more bottles filled?

Funnel, upside-down

A competition in bottle-filling

Observation: The first individual had a comparatively easy task and he has no problem in filling quickly five or six bottles of water. The second individual, however, is confronted with a much more difficult situation, as most of the water drips beside the funnel and does not enter the bottle. Even with much more energy and commitment compared with his opponent, he hardly gets one bottle filled up – and necessarily loses.

Analysis: To hold the funnel the right way gives you a much superior possibility to complete your work.  To hold the funnel upside-down means that even with additional amount of energy you will lag far behind.

Heriniaina Ralaivaha and his experimental view on solidarity

Funnel, solidarity, and society

Mr. Ralaivaha proposes the following reading: To hold the funnel the normal, right way symbolizes a well-orchestred social group, supporting all member. Everybody is conscient that his effort will contribute to the well-being of the group, and to his own as well. The application of ‘solidarity’ allows a relatively easy performance of the work the group aims to. The productivity – in a large sense, including all kind of social, artistic, educational or material goods – is high, symbolized by the number of bottles filled. – To hold the funnel upside-down, however, means that the energy of the given group is not well canalized. A lot, if not most of all energy, of work, is futile and “drips” away, not contributing to the performance of that group. The productivity of this soiecty is fairly low.

To hold the funnel the right way, i.e. to use the secrets of ‘solidarity’, allows a group relatively easy to grow. If the virtues of solidarity are forgotten, i.e. if the funnel is hold the wrong way, the society will not progress.

Further, Ralaivaha even proposes a historical reading. Might the difference between the proper, and the wrong use of the funnels not stay for the important changes from pre-colonial to post-colonial society? But at this point it is perhaps better for everybody to start to reflect oneself about the possibilities to interpret the proposed experiment, and to develop even additional meanings.

Thank you Mr. Ralaivaha for your unusual presentation!


Mr. Heriniaina Ralaivaha

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Framework Programme for Research and Innovation Horizon 2020 (2014-2020) under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie Grant Agreement No. 702497 – DySoMa.


Über Peter Friedrich Alfons Kneitz

561 Kommentare

  1. TOTOMAX sagt:

    Hello, there is no doubt that your blog may have browser compatibility issues. Your blog looks fine on Safari, but there are some overlapping issues when you open it in I.E. I just wanted to give you a quick piece of information! Apart from that, a great site! 메이저사이트

  2. TOTOBLOGS sagt:

    Useful information. Luckily I came across your site, and I was surprised why this accident didn’t happen earlier! I bookmarked it. 사설토토사이트

  3. Fantastic post, very informative. I wonder why other experts don’t notice this. You have to keep writing your writing. You already have a great readership! 플레이포커

  4. I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment

  5. Wonderful web site. Plenty of helpful information here. I am sending it to a few pals and additionally sharing in delicious. And obviously, thank you to your sweat! 먹튀검증

  6. totositerank sagt:

    You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this topic to be actually something which I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for me. 토토사이트

  7. Now, a user can easily update the firmware through the web management window of a Dlink router.

  8. The default web address allows you to login to your device and configure its settings. To login to the Wavlink device, enter the defualt web address in the web browser. Press Enter and you will reach the login page. Enter the login credentials and you will be logged into the device.

  9. Thank you for always useful posts. I also want to share useful posts. If you have any questions about the 토토커뮤니티 please contact us.

  10. I found a very great blog. I’m very curious about how you came to post in various ways. I wish you could let me know. I’ll visit again next time.토토사이트

  11. Thanks so much for the article.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  12. หนังใหม่พากย์ไทย sagt:

    the first time. It’s interesting. Thanks for sharing. Thanks. หนังใหม่พากย์ไทย

  13. That’s an amazing experiment that you have shared !!

  14. It is quite beneficial, although think about the facts when it reaches this target. 슬롯사이트

  15. Really great report. I just discovered your weblog and wished to precise that I have critically appreciated browsing your blog site posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing with your feed And that i hope you compose over again shortly! Pg Slot เว็บใหม่

  16. I am always searching online for storys that can accommodate me. There is obviously a multiple to understand about this 토토벳나비

  17. 무료스포츠중계 sagt:

    I am always searching online for storys that can accommodate me. There is obviously a multiple to understand about this 무료스포츠중계

  18. 해외스포츠중계 sagt:

    „i really like your site its very nice information.



Letzte Kommentare